Judge allows vote on redevelopment zone to move ahead

May 4, 2003

The council majority were able to move ahead with their vote to sell the redevelopment zone to Green Acres, thanks to a judge's ruling. The judge, Robert Passero, did retain control of the proposed sale however, stating that the ordinance may be challenged, and that he reserves the right to stop the sale at any point up to the time when the money changes hands. He did rule that Council member Andy Gargano could vote on the proposed sale.

The council met on April 30th and voted 3-2 to go foward, but still have some other hurdles to cross. The legal notice on the ordinance required was incorrect, so the final votes will be postponed until late May and early June. This leaves the council little time before a new council is seated on July 1. Three of the current council seats - those of Harkey, Moshman, and Weisbecker, are all up for grabs in May. Two golf course proponents are currently running for the Moshman and Weisbecker seats. No candidate emerged for Harkey's seat until recently, when two write in candidates, one in favor of the redevelopment zone, one opposed, appeared.

The other item which could jeopardize the sale is the ownership of Post Brook Lake, which residents say is privately owned and cannot be sold to Green Acres along with the rest of the Redevelopment Zone. Borough attorneys are trying to sort out the matter as quickly as possible to avoid any problems later.

Judge orders stay in move to sell
redevelopment zone

April 27, 2003

Another last-minute wrench has been put into the works in an effort to stop the West Milford Council majority from selling the 466-acre redevelopment zone to Green Acres as open space. Meetings scheduled for April 16th and 23rd were to include the vote to sell the property, for which Green Acres has offered $1.69 million.

True to their word, golf course proponents are not going down without a fight. They filed suit in court to stop the sale, charging the council member Andrew Gargano should recuse himself from any vote due to a conflict of interest.Gargano's father-in-law lives hear the redevelopment zone, but Township Attorney Martin Murphy and another attorney have both stated that no conflict exists.

The judge selected to rule on the case needed time to review the information presented, and directed the council to hold off on any vote until April 28th, when he would rule whether or not the sale could go forward.

The council has scheduled a special meeting for Wednesday, April 30th, hoping that the judge will have ruled on the matter by that date.
As always, CLEAN will keep residents informed of any change in the proposed meeting dates.

West Milford Council votes to sell redevelopment zone to Green Acres

February 28, 2003

West Milford Council voted in February 3-2 to sell approximately 420 acres of the 466-acre redevelopment zone to Green Acres for $1.69 million.  The decision followed a year of heated debate surrounding the property, as pro-development residents pushed for development of the property as a golf course and conference center.  Skylands CLEAN, Pequannock River Coalition (PRC) and environmental activists in the town opposed the plan, stating that the proposed golf course would require 45 million gallons of water per year in a town where many wells were already going dry.  

CLEAN and PRC also challenged tax revenue figures put forth by golf course proponents. The  pro-development group cited a potential increase in revenue of $1.0 million per year, a figure that was never verified.  But CLEAN and PRC showed conclusively that the generous sweetheart deal to promote the plan would exempt the developer from taxes for several years while the development was under construction, eliminating any promised tax gains for another 10-12 years.  

The issue came to a boil when pro-development forces collected signatures of approximately 3500 residents in support of the golf course project.  When a judge decided that the petition was not legal, the group launched a campaign to remove the current council by changing the form of government.  Their efforts resulted in a referendum on  December 10, 2002, allowing for partisan elections of municipal officials, which will mean a complete change of council on January 1, 2004.

Golf Course proponents are unhappy with the proposed sale, charging that the amount offered by Green Acres is too low.  The council has agreed to get another appraisal to ensure the best price and if necessary, push for a better deal.  Pro-development forces vow to fight on, with Mayor Robert Moshman stating that he will challenge the sale in court.  For more background on the redevelopment zone, read the article below.

Millionaire Milks West Milford

If millionaire Wall Street financier Leonard Miller has his way, he’ll receive up to $700,000 when West Milford Township sells property it owns to the state for preservation purposes.That’s on top of the $700,000 he received for repairs to the dam on his lake, and the promise of a publicly-financed road through property he hopes to develop.

Miller purchased a home in West Milford in 1989, after retiring early from a successful Wall Street career.He says he enjoys the peace and quiet of the remote, mountainous township.But shortly after purchasing his home, he began amassing land nearby.In particular, he obtained 36 acres at a bankruptcy sale.The 36 acre-parcel divides larger parcels owned by the Township.In the 1990’s, the Township signed over to Miller an additional 50 or so acres that had been in foreclosure.

The Township had considered building a golf course on their parcels, but with Miller’s 36 acres dividing the Township land, Miller’s cooperation was needed.But Miller convinced the Township to participate in a development project that would bring a hotel, and conference center to town along with the golf course.The project was envisioned for the property owned by the Township, but financed by Miller.Miller has invested about $64,000 so far, while the Township has spent nearly $900,000 on studies for the resort.The current Township council opposes the resort, in part because of environmental concerns about the project.Water supply is also an issue.The facility would require about 100,000 gallons of water per day.

If the project had been completed, Miller would have built and sold luxury homes on his parcel, and would have received one third of the revenues from the resort development.The Township, meanwhile, has spent nearly $900,000 on studies for the resort.

The Township controlled the liens the 36 acres at one time, and could have foreclosed on those properties, removing Miller from the equation.Instead, the Council allowed him to purchase the liens and then negotiated a contract favorable to Miller.

West Milford has been designated a Town Center by the State, which means that the Township will restrict development to the designated Town Center area, in return for funding from the State for downtown improvements.(For more information, see http://www.skyclean.org/wm.html).The proposed resort development lies well outside the Town Center, and lies atop critical watershed lands.Skylands CLEAN has opposed the development from the beginning.The development would bring traffic and air and water pollution to one of the few pristine areas left in northern New Jersey, would endanger water supplies for as many as 4 million New Jersey residents, and would destroy one of the most beautiful scenic vistas in the state.

For more information about the proposed development, contact Skylands CLEAN.

email:clean@skyclean.org